MagicPoppy ([Description: a pretty young woman with long blond hair is dancing in front of a mirror in an open-fronted blouse. Her white toy poodle looks on.])

— image with caption by MagicPoppy. Click on image to visit MagicPoppy @ Tumblr.

Please see our “About,” “Why Radfem?” and “The Gears” pages for additional information about this project.

Women’s culture/positive images.  There seems to be a pattern here: where an image isn’t objectifying women on its face, and where the message conveyed is supportive of women’s interests rather than obviously deleterious to women’s interests, female-positive images are often crafted as a political response to male-supremacist political positions and to patriarchy itself. Most of the images we have used here so far as examples of “Women’s culture/positive images” are not positive images in their own right: these images are necessary now, but would not be necessary and would not exist outside a patriarchal context where women are fighting for our very lives, and use various media to illustrate and advance our points.

Here, the subject of the photograph is not a “pretty young woman” rather, it is obviously a man.  The caption illustrates the mindfuck that is transactivism: at transactivists’ request, we are literally expected to disbelieve our senses when it comes to identifying a subject’s physical sex, in this case, we are supposed to disbelieve our eyesight.  A.k.a. gaslighting, or “don’t believe your lying eyes.”  This is politicking at its most dishonest, and it’s also something men and patriarchal institutions do to women every minute of every day, for example, when psychotherapy and psychotherapists frame women’s negative “lived experience” with men as destructive “baggage” instead of as useful “connections”; or when they attempt to (and often succeed at) disabusing raped women of their perceptions of males as a sexual class as dangerous, sexual predators of women, even though that’s demonstrably true.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , ,

4 responses to “MagicPoppy ([Description: a pretty young woman with long blond hair is dancing in front of a mirror in an open-fronted blouse. Her white toy poodle looks on.])”

  1. magicpoppy says :

    What a great insight.

    I hesitated a bit before posting this gag, but your analysis makes me glad I went through with it. They really are gaslighting us with “anyone who identifies as a woman is one” and the ridiculous descriptions of those exhibitionists on Tumblr like “pretty newly transitioned 40 year old girl.”

  2. FCM says :

    im glad you did it. 🙂 we need more voices of reason out there. and your caption seriously made me laugh. so funny, for reals. thanks for that.

  3. FCM says :

    its also ableist, which makes it even more excellent. i think anyone who was afraid of the third wave thought police might not have attempted the caption bc it kinda pokes fun at the [descriptions done for non-sighted persons reading blogs]. interesting though that non-sighted persons relying on [descriptions] written by trans and gender queers are not going to have anything else to rely on, and will have little choice but to believe what they are being told about whats in the pic. you have pointed out why this is a problem: trans and gender queers lie!